Publication: Pi: University of London Magazine
Date: May, 2001
Transcribed by
Toolfan in London (collegeben@hotmail.com)
Toolfan in London (collegeben@hotmail.com)
page: 12
title: New Releases - Genre: Grindcore, Band: Tool
author: Ben Schachtman
If you peel back enough layers, you will find something redeeming.
This could very well be Tool's mantra of excavational psychology, and
it is true enough in London. If you dig through Chris Evans tyranny
of powder-pop, and continue down through the layers of thoughtless
garage and quasi-house, down past indie-rock self-adoration, you will
find the minging core of the human psyche. Or, to put it less
ostentatiously, there are more Tool fans than you'd except in London.
Less likely the result of a nationalistic affection for British-
borne bassist Justin Chancellor or nostalgia for semi-underground
favorite Peach, Tool’s popularity rests firmly on the integrity and
(perhaps more importantly) humour of Tool’s works. Although their
initial outing was quickly shelved either next to political-rock-rap
masters Rage Against the Machine or drunken-redneck metal ‘gods’
Pantera, many saw through the façade of buzzsaw guitar tones and
Carey’s pyschopathic double bass drumming. Awarded the ridiculous
titles of “grindcore” and “death metal” by a lazy U.S. music press,
Tool did put up an impressive metallic front, but left hints of their
loftier aspirations with the dreamy chorus of the opener “Sweat”,
which was embarrassingly relegated to the Escape From L.A.
Soundtrack. With the closer (yes, we are ignoring the “Gaping Lotus
Experience”, but that’s our prerogative) Tool left the general
impression that they would be back, if only to free themselves from
the “grindcore” section in the Virgin Megastore.
Undertow, an ethereal and original work, helped slowly
extricate Tool from the “grindcore” bin (honestly though, who the
fuck thought up ‘grindcore’? It either takes bollocks of steel or
brains of concrete). Tool fans don’t need the album described to
them, and for the uninitiated nothing would describe it aptly,
suffice to say, anyone who was getting tired of Metallica’s odes to
H.P. Lovecraft characters found a welcome rubber-hose up the psyche
in this album. It should be added that the extendedly odd
finale, “disgustipated”, found on track 69 (clever Yankees), is
arguably the funniest thing ever put to CD. Of special note to the
rock world: Adam Jones thought of drop-B tuning for the droning verse
and brutally low chorus of “Prison Sex” long before Munky and Head
even considered it. Also, Tool let the occasionally brilliant Henry
Rollins flex his muscular spoken word presence on “Bottom”. Show me
another “grindcore” band with spoken word poetry and I’ll swim the
Thames for you. Tool took the “Undertow” album on tour with a
genuinely inspired live-show (occasionally handing off Henry’s spoken
word duties to Zack de la Rocha, who had likewise invited singer
Maynard James Keenan to add his talents to “Know Your Enemy”).
Aenima, the album a thousand DJs couldn’t pronounce, found
Tool leaving the so called “nu-metal” (seriously, they must not pay
the American music press, because we can’t imagine paying someone to
invent ‘nu’-metal) with the furious ‘fuck-off’ of “Hooker with a
Penis” thrown over their shoulder. With massive arrangements of what
could arguably be called art-rock and even-more-indulgent interludes,
Aenima was a contradiction. A massively talented work that dared you
to enjoy it, understand it, or pronounce it. For those in the
diminishing hard-rock fan base who could get their heads around
Aenima, it was well worth the effort. Eventually critics, even the
notoriously star-fucking Spin Magazine, came around and lavished
considerably overdue praise of Tool, who all but disappeared into a
avalanche of legal troubles and (how dare they) private lives and
side projects.
The patient fans put Aenima in heavy rotation and decided to
spent the next five years deciphering it, while the more eager
tripped over pranks and April fool’s jokes, believing that Floorpail
(that’s right, April Fool) would be the next single, grieving when
Tool died in a bus crash, and waiting around for four years to hear
the supposedly twenty minute studio recording of Led Zeppelin’s “No
Quarter.” Finally rewarded this Christmas, Tool eventually decided to
briefly resurface to release “Salival”, a small but potent collection
of odds and ends for the faithful to chew on until they came around
to where they are now.
[Note from Kabir - Nice of them mentioning TWO toolshed April Fools' gags]
Now is the moment we’ve all waited for. Having triumphed
their legal woes, dodged the bubonic breakup plague that swept the
alternative rock scene, and apparently ten times wiser for the wear,
Tool has prepared to drop “Lateralus” (no, it won’t be called Maynard
Sings Pavoratti, The Mental Fuckwithage Project, or something in
Sumarian, but then again if you thought Tool was going to
release “Buzz’s Revenge” as the first single, you might still be
looking for new releases in the “grindcore” bin) on the world.
By a blessed twist of commercialistic fate, the U.K. will
receive our dose of Tool a day before the States, and the appetites
are more than whet. The first single, greedily grasped off file-
sharing programs by fans who wouldn’t wait three more days for the
official website to stream it online, gives us a taste of what is on
the new orb from the Tool mothership.
“Schism” starts with a Justin Chancellor noodle, and quickly
gets picked up by the whole band, who latch onto it’s quirky as all
get-out time signature until they can pry a face-crushing riff out of
it. Then there is the obligatory but never the less effective
breakdown, which finds Tool in another, equally quirky time signature
and forces the listener to wait until the last thirty seconds for the
violently propulsive and entertainingly cathartic ending, which
builds so much momentum its impressive Tool managed to stop at all,
much less on a sixpence.
Now, less we be accused of praising only Chancellor, (though
he went under praised for his work on Aenima, having stepped in half
way through the writing) Tool’s guitar tour-de-force is executed by
Adam Jones, who has fattened his guitar sound even more and tweaked
his tones to keep Tool fans slightly unnerved and thoroughly
addicted. Riff junkies will get their fixes right up front
on “Lateralus”, but those who stay for the subtle and brooding guitar
work will be genuinely rewarded. You won’t be humming these tunes,
unless you can handle Arabic minor runs in odd tempos (if you can,
you could make a killing busking, I guarantee it), but you will be
sweating like a smack junkie for another listen shortly after hearing
them.
Singer Maynard has, in our humble opinion, come into his own
on Lateralus. His outing with A Perfect Circle (no, that wasn’t Tool
doing “Judith”) provided a lot of more emotive singing, but Tool has
been moving in that direction even without Billy Howerdel's
influence. Anyone who has heard their awe-inspiring live “Pushit”
(which on its own Salival is worth buying for) could see a band
becoming more and more emotionally as well as musically potent. And
many would have our heads if we exempted Drummer Carey from our
scathing praise. Truth be told, Carey is as ever masterful. Whereas
fellow disciple of the polyrhythmic dojo Carter Beauford (whose
amazing talent is venerable no matter what you think of the band,
trust us) opted for four-on-the-floor simplicity as Dave Matthew’s
Band rose to fame, Carey has taken the chance to push the envelope,
playing with, and indeed outside, the very conceptions of modern
drumming. (A good friend of ours at Pi offered the following
comment: “He’s a prick, a fucking sod, an arse, he’s a fucking
irritating bastard,” and after a long thoughtful pause, “I love that
man, he’s my god.” We didn’t show him the demo tape, because we
didn’t want him to quit drumming forever, but we can’t hide Carey’s
amazing skills forever).
Pi got our hands on this dub-of-a-dub-of-a-dub copy
previously owed by an editor (who shall go unnamed, but his
notoriously bad Snooker skills cost him this gem…that’s a hint if you
know him) at Kerrang! – and we decided not to review it for you.
Lateralus will be out very soon ladies and gentleman, and there are
more than enough prick-tease pre-reviews of Lateralus for our tastes
without adding another to the pyre. In addition, we are greatly
concerned for our own reputation, lest we accidentally add something
of the ridiculous character of “grindcore” to the music critic’s
lexicon. Thusly, we offer this summation by the numbers.
1) Tool, as a band, are a fabulously talented and cohesive group
who have made an international multimillion dollar industry out of
thinking first and recording second, a bite to eat for the minds of
would-be nu-metal rockers out there.
2) Despite this talent, its not how big Carey’s gong is (though
it is huge), or what brand bass Justin plays (it is a custom Wal four
string, in case you think we don’t know) or which pedal Adam is using
to make that noise (our guesss, Digi-tech whammy pedal with some
subtle wah) or where Maynard got that mask (from a college production
of Phantom of the Opera) – it is what they do with it that matters, a
second serving for the speed + volume = quality school of music
(Pantera, we’re looking at you).
3) There really is a lot that you could learn, if you were to
put aside anything else you believe and just listen to them.
4) Lateralus is the most challenging thing you will listen to
for a long time, and it is very likely it will take a while to reach
you, give it time, give it a change, don’t except Papa Roach (for
those of you who think that they didn’t steal the “Last Resort” riff
from Green Day’s “Brain Stew”, gratuitous bollocks to you) and you
might stand a chance. Also, don’t trip by yourself in a dark room to
this album, we had first-year try this with the “Schism” single
alone, and now he speaks in tongues, Babylonian actually…
But most importantly, always remember that when Tool has finally
reached right across the cosmos and touched your psyche with a
perfectly crafted magnum opus, when they’ve finally distilled for you
the very essence of the pure emotion that all humans share and put it
across to you irrefutably and with devastating power and finesse,
when you are sure beyond a shadow of a doubt that Maynard James
Keenan is exactly right about everything and would make an excellent
Gubernatorial candidate for California, and you get your four hundred
greenbacks and go to get the “Lateralus” artwork tattooed across your
forehead, when you have come fully and happily into the church of
Tool, remember:
5) They’re taking the piss.
Having said that, they are still outstanding musicians and performers
(and comedians too). There are plenty of people in Tool’s footsteps,
and plenty of them are quite talented, we look to the Deftones for a
clear example of Tool’s beneficial influence of the rock world.
However, no one does it better than Tool, and Tool has never done it
better than with “Lateralus”, which we’ll get our hands on one day
before the poor sods in the colonies on May 14th.
Posted to t.d.n: 05/06/01 18:56:33