Publication: MTV Online
Date: October 1996
[Kabir's note -- From a KMFDM single: "Slogans like 'Free Your Mind' can only mean one thing -- Turn off your MTV and think for yourselves."] MTV Online/Reviews Tool Aenima (Zoo) 'Believe in nothing' is the Tool mantra, and with a creepy eyeball cover, a loopy liner note diatribe advocating "ritual magik," and three distinct tributes to the late outlaw political comic, Bill Hicks, Tool's dark blueprint for Aenima is obvious even before the first listen. This follow-up to 1993's platinum Undertow is indeed the dreary art-rock landmark the packaging suggests, but the 77 minutes it takes for Tool to rehash, regurgitate, and refilter the same trippy angst winds up overshadowing the thematic achievement. Aenima ain't pretty; we get it. But this monochromatic record refuses to end. Apparently, Tool's belief in nothing extends to the value of a well-crafted, three-minute song. As befits a frontman, Tool songwriter/spiritual leader Maynard James Keenan is perhaps the guiltiest party here, dragging out each syllable as if it were his last breath. "Constant over-stimulation numbs me/and I wouldn't have it any other way," Keenan wails in overkill a verse into the opening "Stinkfist," perhaps answering the question: Completely poignant or consistently unnecessary? Progressive rock fans will ultimately be the judge, since Aenima is clearly guided more by the legacy of Yes, King Crimson, and Pink Floyd than by contemporaries like Rage Against The Machine or Pantera. It's no wonder: producer Dave Bottrill had a hand in the '70s' excesses as former Crimson and Peter Gabriel knobturner. To his credit, he's smart enough to leave the metallic hooks firmly at the forefront here. (They do get away from him, though, in the trippier passages of "Eulogy" and "H.") Equally problematic is Keenan's lack of lyrical maturation. Lifting Hicks' "Arizona Bay" California earthquake reference for the title track is genius, but it is easily deflated by throwaway lines like "Followed by faultlines that cannot sit still/followed by millions of dumbfounded dipshits." Keenan wants to be a protest poet, but "dipshit" is his vocabulary choice? But suppose that Aenima's bloated unfriendliness is actually symbolism for its real statement. Could Tool be asking us to decry one-hit-wonder pop dribble by cleverly delivering a record that is, if nothing else, challenging? The anti-music biz "Hooker With A Penis" is a good test of the theory, with Keenan nicely coming off as genuinely dumbfounded by his own major label/no sellout paradox. It's notably the record's least structured or melodic tune, but may be the literal and theoretical centerpiece, acting as Cliff's Notes for the psychobabble paranoia that precedes it and facilitating a snappier finish. But even if antiestablishmentism is your thing, 77 minutes is a long time to wait for the cathartic statement--especially if you've already been waiting three-and-a-half years since their last record. -- Andy Langer